The China Mail - India at 75: upending narratives and rewriting history

USD -
AED 3.6725
AFN 66.272138
ALL 83.49892
AMD 382.462203
ANG 1.789982
AOA 917.000142
ARS 1405.846866
AUD 1.540453
AWG 1.805
AZN 1.731461
BAM 1.689676
BBD 2.011145
BDT 121.87473
BGN 1.689676
BHD 0.373737
BIF 2940.647948
BMD 1
BND 1.300389
BOB 6.909719
BRL 5.332397
BSD 0.998531
BTN 88.502808
BWP 13.406479
BYN 3.40311
BYR 19600
BZD 2.008207
CAD 1.40548
CDF 2149.999523
CHF 0.805099
CLF 0.024015
CLP 942.090713
CNY 7.11935
CNH 7.12642
COP 3780.302376
CRC 501.339093
CUC 1
CUP 26.5
CVE 95.261339
CZK 21.042005
DJF 177.814255
DKK 6.45971
DOP 64.155508
DZD 129.316631
EGP 46.977086
ERN 15
ETB 154.143499
EUR 0.864899
FJD 2.28425
FKP 0.760233
GBP 0.76438
GEL 2.705031
GGP 0.760233
GHS 10.919222
GIP 0.760233
GMD 73.000117
GNF 8667.818575
GTQ 7.651836
GYD 208.907127
HKD 7.77701
HNL 26.25486
HRK 6.514103
HTG 132.907127
HUF 332.749501
IDR 16685.5
ILS 3.26205
IMP 0.760233
INR 88.665498
IQD 1308.077754
IRR 42099.999831
ISK 126.580387
JEP 0.760233
JMD 160.267819
JOD 0.708985
JPY 153.830583
KES 129.209503
KGS 87.449752
KHR 4019.006479
KMF 421.000259
KPW 900.018268
KRW 1455.999746
KWD 0.306898
KYD 0.832138
KZT 524.198704
LAK 21680.345572
LBP 89418.488121
LKR 304.354212
LRD 182.332613
LSL 17.296674
LTL 2.95274
LVL 0.60489
LYD 5.452268
MAD 9.256069
MDL 17.024622
MGA 4488.12095
MKD 53.153348
MMK 2099.87471
MNT 3580.787673
MOP 7.998963
MRU 39.553348
MUR 45.910255
MVR 15.405011
MWK 1731.490281
MXN 18.451957
MYR 4.17602
MZN 63.949932
NAD 17.296674
NGN 1435.999884
NIO 36.742981
NOK 10.168435
NPR 141.60432
NZD 1.778081
OMR 0.38114
PAB 0.998618
PEN 3.369762
PGK 4.215983
PHP 58.8055
PKR 282.349719
PLN 3.666883
PYG 7065.226782
QAR 3.639309
RON 4.398801
RSD 101.226782
RUB 81.02032
RWF 1450.885529
SAR 3.750397
SBD 8.230592
SCR 13.701253
SDG 600.497235
SEK 9.539425
SGD 1.301685
SHP 0.750259
SLE 23.204398
SLL 20969.499529
SOS 570.62635
SRD 38.598973
STD 20697.981008
STN 21.166307
SVC 8.736933
SYP 11056.858374
SZL 17.302808
THB 32.395028
TJS 9.216415
TMT 3.51
TND 2.95162
TOP 2.342104
TRY 42.23125
TTD 6.768898
TWD 30.981803
TZS 2456.414687
UAH 41.870929
UGX 3494.600432
UYU 39.766739
UZS 12042.332613
VES 228.194028
VND 26310
VUV 122.303025
WST 2.820887
XAF 566.701512
XAG 0.020684
XAU 0.00025
XCD 2.70255
XCG 1.799568
XDR 0.704795
XOF 566.701512
XPF 103.032397
YER 238.498529
ZAR 17.31875
ZMK 9001.25954
ZMW 22.591793
ZWL 321.999592
  • SCS

    0.0000

    15.76

    0%

  • NGG

    1.4600

    77.75

    +1.88%

  • AZN

    0.8100

    84.58

    +0.96%

  • CMSD

    0.0900

    24.1

    +0.37%

  • BTI

    0.3800

    54.59

    +0.7%

  • RYCEF

    0.0800

    14.88

    +0.54%

  • RIO

    0.0600

    69.33

    +0.09%

  • CMSC

    0.0700

    23.85

    +0.29%

  • GSK

    -0.4700

    46.63

    -1.01%

  • RBGPF

    -0.7800

    75.22

    -1.04%

  • BCC

    -0.0900

    70.64

    -0.13%

  • BCE

    0.0200

    23.19

    +0.09%

  • JRI

    -0.0100

    13.74

    -0.07%

  • RELX

    -1.1200

    42.27

    -2.65%

  • VOD

    0.2400

    11.58

    +2.07%

  • BP

    0.7600

    36.58

    +2.08%

India at 75: upending narratives and rewriting history
India at 75: upending narratives and rewriting history / Photo: © AFP

India at 75: upending narratives and rewriting history

The palatial family home of India's first prime minister Jawaharlal Nehru, the freedom struggle stalwart and close confidant of Mahatma Gandhi, is now a museum where loyalists come to pay tribute.

Text size:

But 75 years after independence, that history is being rewritten across the country as the ruling Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) seeks to promote its own Hindu nationalist agenda.

Critics accuse the BJP of upending settled narratives to fit its outlook, promoting the roles of its ideological forebears, and downgrading the contributions of Muslims to Indian history and society.

The BJP ousted Nehru's Congress party at elections in 2014, after the dynasty he founded had dominated Indian politics for decades.

His daughter Indira Gandhi, who grew up in the house, and grandson Rajiv both went on to become prime ministers.

Today, whether the emperor Akbar –- of the Muslim Mughal dynasty that ruled India for 300 years –- won or lost a key battle against a revered Hindu king depends on which textbook is being used.

At the launch of a book on Hindu kings' resistance to the Mughals, home minister Amit Shah -- a key ally of Prime Minister Narendra Modi -- declared: "No one can stop us from writing the truth. We are now independent. We can write our own history."

And the city where Nehru's house stands has been renamed Prayagraj, after being known for 450 years as Allahabad, a moniker bestowed by Akbar.

According to Vinod Mishra, who has worked there for 15 years, the building's visitors illustrate the changing approaches to history.

"Earlier everyone came here in awe and admiration but now many look at the home, his belongings, and quip that he too made a lot of money like other [corrupt] politicians," Mishra told AFP.

Older visitors "still enter each room and reverentially touch the feet of Nehru's portraits", he said, but younger generations are more irreverent.

"It's fascinating to see that he had things like a tennis racket, tea kettle, a shaver and even went to London, which most people still can't afford," said engineering student Amar Yadav, 18.

- 'Imaginary barbaric past' -

Often accused of anti-Muslim rhetoric, BJP leaders have described the Mughals as Islamic invaders, increasing the anxieties of the country's 210-million-odd Muslims.

But they say the authors who dominated historiography after independence from Britain in 1947 glorified conquerors over local kings and achievements.

And they say they over-emphasised Congress's role in the independence struggle, denying the more revolutionary or nationalist figures the BJP reveres their due.

Modi often criticises Nehru -- blaming him for the festering dispute over Kashmir, or losing a 1962 war to China -- to target Congress, still the main opposition party and controlled by the Nehru-Gandhi family.

The BJP's efforts to rewrite the past "aren't just about history but securing its own place in the present for the next few decades", S. Irfan Habib, a New Delhi-based historian told AFP.

"It's dangerous as these books mould young minds who'll grow with a very different understanding of India," Habib said.

"The government in power has full majority and there's nothing much one can do," he added.

Contemporary history is also being reworked, say Indian media: a top official body slashed school textbook content this year.

Among the deletions were the Gujarat riots that killed at least 1,000 people, mostly Muslims, in 2002 -- when Modi was the state's premier.

It was one of India's worst outbreaks of religious violence in recent times, and one removed passage reportedly warned that such events "alert us to the dangers involved in using religious sentiments for political purposes".

- 'Insult to India' -

The states of Haryana and Gujarat have announced the addition of a Hindu holy book to the school curriculum, despite the education system being secular.

A Karnataka textbook incorporated a speech by the founder of the right-wing Rashtriya Swayamsewak Sangh, the BJP's ideological fountainhead.

Rahul Gandhi, Nehru's great-grandson and a Congress party leader, slammed it as an "attempt to teach children saffronised lessons... an insult to India, which is the cradle of diversity".

Saffron, the sacred colour of Hindu monks' robes, is a part of the BJP flag.

Another book in the same state claimed that Vinayak Damodar Savarkar, a right-wing revolutionary jailed by the British, made regular excursions from his jail cell on the wings of small birds.

Savarkar's biographer Vikram Sampath condemned the "stupid insertion".

He is one of the young historians who support "decolonisation" of Indian history, but want to see quality maintained during revisions.

India was "slowly maturing as a democracy", he said, hoping for a time when "historical characters won't get caught in the slug fest of contemporary electoral politics".

- 'Greatest con job' -

For some, the history textbook changes fit into the ruling party's agenda of appealing to the country's Hindu majority.

The BJP has backed several big-ticket projects including a grand temple corridor in Varanasi, a mega statue to a Hindu warrior king who successfully challenged the Mughals, and a grand temple at the Ayodhya site where zealots destroyed a Mughal-era mosque three decades ago.

Now emboldened right-wing groups have laid fresh claims to several Muslim sites they say were built atop temples destroyed during Islamic rule, raising fears of violence.

Some of them question the contributions of non-Hindu rulers, and the merits of secularism in an overwhelmingly Hindu country of about 1.4 billion people.

"What did the Islamic invasions do for this country in 1,400 years of onslaught?" said Omendra Ratnu, who wrote the book launched by home minister Shah.

"They built three buildings -- Taj Mahal, Red Fort and the Qutub Minar -- and all three are disputed, have Hindu claims," he told AFP.

Mainstream Indian history was a "con job ... by some very crafty and wicked people", he said, adding textbook revisions were "baby steps -- but steps in the right direction".

C.Smith--ThChM