The China Mail - India at 75: upending narratives and rewriting history

USD -
AED 3.672501
AFN 65.476319
ALL 80.577087
AMD 365.860022
ANG 1.789783
AOA 917.000049
ARS 1491.641402
AUD 1.41719
AWG 1.80125
AZN 1.697547
BAM 1.696734
BBD 2.015728
BDT 122.843622
BGN 1.696366
BHD 0.377075
BIF 2998
BMD 1
BND 1.280933
BOB 11.734342
BRL 5.209199
BSD 1.000794
BTN 95.468406
BWP 13.472141
BYN 3.009929
BYR 19600
BZD 2.012779
CAD 1.393785
CDF 2273.000256
CHF 0.813435
CLF 0.023231
CLP 914.290229
CNY 6.743198
CNH 6.745195
COP 3125.44
CRC 449.393362
CUC 1
CUP 26.5
CVE 96.097828
CZK 21.014198
DJF 178.218681
DKK 6.484485
DOP 58.508892
DZD 132.931669
EGP 50.176501
ERN 15
ETB 161.890385
EUR 0.86745
FJD 2.21445
FKP 0.740201
GBP 0.741685
GEL 2.610218
GGP 0.740201
GHS 11.074982
GIP 0.740201
GMD 73.501678
GNF 8774.999914
GTQ 7.628599
GYD 209.38434
HKD 7.84715
HNL 26.830633
HRK 6.535402
HTG 130.904201
HUF 315.257502
IDR 17864
ILS 2.962965
IMP 0.740201
INR 95.43215
IQD 1311.025996
IRR 1374587.497717
ISK 123.34037
JEP 0.740201
JMD 158.336044
JOD 0.708968
JPY 159.5095
KES 129.495898
KGS 87.449705
KHR 4047.49823
KMF 426.999894
KPW 900.000294
KRW 1418.620493
KWD 0.30861
KYD 0.834053
KZT 465.738688
LAK 22580.225386
LBP 89621.102036
LKR 333.612392
LRD 181.645463
LSL 16.144844
LTL 2.95274
LVL 0.604889
LYD 6.374682
MAD 9.270009
MDL 17.373275
MGA 4310.91697
MKD 53.37538
MMK 2099.846019
MNT 3597.969266
MOP 8.08894
MRU 40.105493
MUR 47.149798
MVR 15.460087
MWK 1735.471585
MXN 17.04444
MYR 4.086397
MZN 63.900861
NAD 16.144914
NGN 1360.849945
NIO 36.82706
NOK 9.513135
NPR 152.752101
NZD 1.71006
OMR 0.384513
PAB 1.000794
PEN 3.377159
PGK 4.42879
PHP 61.374501
PKR 277.795321
PLN 3.7389
PYG 5973.01084
QAR 3.635016
RON 4.547598
RSD 101.752974
RUB 83.076096
RWF 1474.223003
SAR 3.743113
SBD 8.064941
SCR 14.023536
SDG 600.498289
SEK 9.568698
SGD 1.28072
SHP 0.740866
SLE 24.550085
SLL 20969.499227
SOS 571.973887
SRD 37.722498
STD 20697.981008
STN 21.254723
SVC 8.756946
SYP 13001.999906
SZL 16.149252
THB 33.194033
TJS 9.247366
TMT 3.5
TND 2.934571
TOP 2.40776
TRY 47.773796
TTD 6.786763
TWD 32.126993
TZS 2645.502939
UAH 44.737671
UGX 3715.737009
UYU 40.062929
UZS 11954.697077
VES 765.397601
VND 26075
VUV 118.594628
WST 2.730779
XAF 569.073676
XAG 0.015463
XAU 0.000229
XCD 2.70255
XCG 1.803702
XDR 0.707757
XOF 569.06874
XPF 103.462785
YER 237.149877
ZAR 16.21045
ZMK 9001.20247
ZMW 18.815201
ZWL 321.999592
  • RBGPF

    0.0000

    72.16

    0%

  • CMSD

    0.0100

    21.6

    +0.05%

  • CMSC

    0.0000

    21.45

    0%

  • BCE

    0.0250

    23.155

    +0.11%

  • BCC

    -0.4000

    83.85

    -0.48%

  • NGG

    0.3950

    81.075

    +0.49%

  • RIO

    -2.8050

    98.415

    -2.85%

  • JRI

    -0.0210

    12.689

    -0.17%

  • GSK

    0.1850

    50.485

    +0.37%

  • RELX

    -0.5500

    34

    -1.62%

  • AZN

    -0.7600

    157.74

    -0.48%

  • BP

    -0.0750

    42.855

    -0.18%

  • RYCEF

    0.1700

    20.71

    +0.82%

  • VOD

    0.1100

    16.2

    +0.68%

  • BTI

    1.5450

    57.385

    +2.69%

India at 75: upending narratives and rewriting history
India at 75: upending narratives and rewriting history / Photo: © AFP

India at 75: upending narratives and rewriting history

The palatial family home of India's first prime minister Jawaharlal Nehru, the freedom struggle stalwart and close confidant of Mahatma Gandhi, is now a museum where loyalists come to pay tribute.

Text size:

But 75 years after independence, that history is being rewritten across the country as the ruling Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) seeks to promote its own Hindu nationalist agenda.

Critics accuse the BJP of upending settled narratives to fit its outlook, promoting the roles of its ideological forebears, and downgrading the contributions of Muslims to Indian history and society.

The BJP ousted Nehru's Congress party at elections in 2014, after the dynasty he founded had dominated Indian politics for decades.

His daughter Indira Gandhi, who grew up in the house, and grandson Rajiv both went on to become prime ministers.

Today, whether the emperor Akbar –- of the Muslim Mughal dynasty that ruled India for 300 years –- won or lost a key battle against a revered Hindu king depends on which textbook is being used.

At the launch of a book on Hindu kings' resistance to the Mughals, home minister Amit Shah -- a key ally of Prime Minister Narendra Modi -- declared: "No one can stop us from writing the truth. We are now independent. We can write our own history."

And the city where Nehru's house stands has been renamed Prayagraj, after being known for 450 years as Allahabad, a moniker bestowed by Akbar.

According to Vinod Mishra, who has worked there for 15 years, the building's visitors illustrate the changing approaches to history.

"Earlier everyone came here in awe and admiration but now many look at the home, his belongings, and quip that he too made a lot of money like other [corrupt] politicians," Mishra told AFP.

Older visitors "still enter each room and reverentially touch the feet of Nehru's portraits", he said, but younger generations are more irreverent.

"It's fascinating to see that he had things like a tennis racket, tea kettle, a shaver and even went to London, which most people still can't afford," said engineering student Amar Yadav, 18.

- 'Imaginary barbaric past' -

Often accused of anti-Muslim rhetoric, BJP leaders have described the Mughals as Islamic invaders, increasing the anxieties of the country's 210-million-odd Muslims.

But they say the authors who dominated historiography after independence from Britain in 1947 glorified conquerors over local kings and achievements.

And they say they over-emphasised Congress's role in the independence struggle, denying the more revolutionary or nationalist figures the BJP reveres their due.

Modi often criticises Nehru -- blaming him for the festering dispute over Kashmir, or losing a 1962 war to China -- to target Congress, still the main opposition party and controlled by the Nehru-Gandhi family.

The BJP's efforts to rewrite the past "aren't just about history but securing its own place in the present for the next few decades", S. Irfan Habib, a New Delhi-based historian told AFP.

"It's dangerous as these books mould young minds who'll grow with a very different understanding of India," Habib said.

"The government in power has full majority and there's nothing much one can do," he added.

Contemporary history is also being reworked, say Indian media: a top official body slashed school textbook content this year.

Among the deletions were the Gujarat riots that killed at least 1,000 people, mostly Muslims, in 2002 -- when Modi was the state's premier.

It was one of India's worst outbreaks of religious violence in recent times, and one removed passage reportedly warned that such events "alert us to the dangers involved in using religious sentiments for political purposes".

- 'Insult to India' -

The states of Haryana and Gujarat have announced the addition of a Hindu holy book to the school curriculum, despite the education system being secular.

A Karnataka textbook incorporated a speech by the founder of the right-wing Rashtriya Swayamsewak Sangh, the BJP's ideological fountainhead.

Rahul Gandhi, Nehru's great-grandson and a Congress party leader, slammed it as an "attempt to teach children saffronised lessons... an insult to India, which is the cradle of diversity".

Saffron, the sacred colour of Hindu monks' robes, is a part of the BJP flag.

Another book in the same state claimed that Vinayak Damodar Savarkar, a right-wing revolutionary jailed by the British, made regular excursions from his jail cell on the wings of small birds.

Savarkar's biographer Vikram Sampath condemned the "stupid insertion".

He is one of the young historians who support "decolonisation" of Indian history, but want to see quality maintained during revisions.

India was "slowly maturing as a democracy", he said, hoping for a time when "historical characters won't get caught in the slug fest of contemporary electoral politics".

- 'Greatest con job' -

For some, the history textbook changes fit into the ruling party's agenda of appealing to the country's Hindu majority.

The BJP has backed several big-ticket projects including a grand temple corridor in Varanasi, a mega statue to a Hindu warrior king who successfully challenged the Mughals, and a grand temple at the Ayodhya site where zealots destroyed a Mughal-era mosque three decades ago.

Now emboldened right-wing groups have laid fresh claims to several Muslim sites they say were built atop temples destroyed during Islamic rule, raising fears of violence.

Some of them question the contributions of non-Hindu rulers, and the merits of secularism in an overwhelmingly Hindu country of about 1.4 billion people.

"What did the Islamic invasions do for this country in 1,400 years of onslaught?" said Omendra Ratnu, who wrote the book launched by home minister Shah.

"They built three buildings -- Taj Mahal, Red Fort and the Qutub Minar -- and all three are disputed, have Hindu claims," he told AFP.

Mainstream Indian history was a "con job ... by some very crafty and wicked people", he said, adding textbook revisions were "baby steps -- but steps in the right direction".

C.Smith--ThChM