The China Mail - India at 75: upending narratives and rewriting history

USD -
AED 3.6725
AFN 64.999747
ALL 81.855804
AMD 362.20984
ANG 1.790365
AOA 918.000201
ARS 1516.745904
AUD 1.437122
AWG 1.8
AZN 1.692219
BAM 1.75007
BBD 2.014862
BDT 123.150572
BGN 1.683441
BHD 0.377597
BIF 2993.213105
BMD 1
BND 1.281167
BOB 11.849764
BRL 4.9869
BSD 1.000362
BTN 95.757408
BWP 13.762835
BYN 3.017158
BYR 19600
BZD 2.011999
CAD 1.428435
CDF 2309.999714
CHF 0.83455
CLF 0.024821
CLP 976.870209
CNY 6.692149
CNH 6.69485
COP 3195.84
CRC 455.621222
CUC 1
CUP 24.010451
CVE 98.666285
CZK 21.834202
DJF 177.720107
DKK 6.69878
DOP 60.747601
DZD 134.682039
EGP 52.653301
ERN 15
ETB 163.410241
EUR 0.896103
FJD 2.24725
FKP 0.755381
GBP 0.757125
GEL 2.590212
GGP 0.755381
GHS 11.764759
GIP 0.755381
GMD 73.507189
GNF 8801.199025
GTQ 7.647672
GYD 209.197346
HKD 7.84803
HNL 26.853679
HRK 6.7512
HTG 131.006868
HUF 326.919042
IDR 17925.55
ILS 3.07312
IMP 0.755381
INR 95.602749
IQD 1516.587254
IRR 1779470.000482
ISK 122.050438
JEP 0.755381
JMD 159.428395
JOD 0.708972
JPY 158.659504
KES 129.739901
KGS 87.449746
KHR 4061.472384
KMF 439.999937
KPW 900.000318
KRW 1334.490027
KWD 0.31143
KYD 0.83368
KZT 450.673097
LAK 22494.642322
LBP 89587.097063
LKR 331.142539
LRD 170.576208
LSL 16.549941
LTL 2.95274
LVL 0.60489
LYD 6.428319
MAD 9.679166
MDL 17.917366
MGA 4512.529585
MKD 55.100461
MMK 2100.025299
MNT 3596.153429
MOP 8.086399
MRU 40.212066
MUR 47.530113
MVR 15.449866
MWK 1734.769206
MXN 18.241315
MYR 4.085097
MZN 63.90987
NAD 16.549941
NGN 1330.260028
NIO 36.811188
NOK 9.573036
NPR 153.214773
NZD 1.790478
OMR 0.384504
PAB 1.00038
PEN 3.44445
PGK 4.471368
PHP 62.768499
PKR 276.99451
PLN 3.928315
PYG 5690.893229
QAR 3.657001
RON 4.778004
RSD 105.192003
RUB 83.910765
RWF 1475.068787
SAR 3.75677
SBD 8.078071
SCR 14.002831
SDG 601.503172
SEK 10.040275
SGD 1.281045
SHP 0.755572
SLE 24.669871
SLL 20969.491881
SOS 571.773706
SRD 37.667024
STD 20697.981008
STN 21.922074
SVC 8.753932
SYP 13002.000254
SZL 16.544455
THB 33.63003
TJS 9.218882
TMT 3.51
TND 2.992694
TOP 2.40776
TRY 49.330503
TTD 6.803001
TWD 31.94401
TZS 2640.008042
UAH 45.034652
UGX 4132.087205
UYU 40.23891
UZS 11905.241259
VES 875.701598
VND 25937
VUV 119.754657
WST 2.785507
XAF 587.804931
XAG 0.016586
XAU 0.000239761581
XCD 2.70255
XCG 1.802979
XDR 0.707052
XOF 587.804931
XPF 106.711286
YER 236.199723
ZAR 16.54505
ZMK 9001.20052
ZMW 19.858175
ZWL 321.999592
SSP 5757.531856
MXV 2.060114
  • RYCEF

    0.4000

    19.71

    +2.03%

  • CMSC

    0.0000

    20.4

    0%

  • BTI

    0.4200

    56.05

    +0.75%

  • BP

    0.2800

    44.43

    +0.63%

  • RBGPF

    1.6000

    67

    +2.39%

  • RIO

    -0.1500

    94.41

    -0.16%

  • AZN

    -0.4300

    166.15

    -0.26%

  • GSK

    0.4600

    49.7

    +0.93%

  • BCE

    -0.4100

    20.56

    -1.99%

  • NGG

    -0.2500

    75.24

    -0.33%

  • VOD

    -0.0400

    16.58

    -0.24%

  • RELX

    -0.4500

    33.07

    -1.36%

  • BCC

    -0.5500

    76.59

    -0.72%

  • CMSD

    -0.0300

    20.27

    -0.15%

  • JRI

    -0.2500

    10.77

    -2.32%

India at 75: upending narratives and rewriting history
India at 75: upending narratives and rewriting history / Photo: © AFP

India at 75: upending narratives and rewriting history

The palatial family home of India's first prime minister Jawaharlal Nehru, the freedom struggle stalwart and close confidant of Mahatma Gandhi, is now a museum where loyalists come to pay tribute.

Text size:

But 75 years after independence, that history is being rewritten across the country as the ruling Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) seeks to promote its own Hindu nationalist agenda.

Critics accuse the BJP of upending settled narratives to fit its outlook, promoting the roles of its ideological forebears, and downgrading the contributions of Muslims to Indian history and society.

The BJP ousted Nehru's Congress party at elections in 2014, after the dynasty he founded had dominated Indian politics for decades.

His daughter Indira Gandhi, who grew up in the house, and grandson Rajiv both went on to become prime ministers.

Today, whether the emperor Akbar –- of the Muslim Mughal dynasty that ruled India for 300 years –- won or lost a key battle against a revered Hindu king depends on which textbook is being used.

At the launch of a book on Hindu kings' resistance to the Mughals, home minister Amit Shah -- a key ally of Prime Minister Narendra Modi -- declared: "No one can stop us from writing the truth. We are now independent. We can write our own history."

And the city where Nehru's house stands has been renamed Prayagraj, after being known for 450 years as Allahabad, a moniker bestowed by Akbar.

According to Vinod Mishra, who has worked there for 15 years, the building's visitors illustrate the changing approaches to history.

"Earlier everyone came here in awe and admiration but now many look at the home, his belongings, and quip that he too made a lot of money like other [corrupt] politicians," Mishra told AFP.

Older visitors "still enter each room and reverentially touch the feet of Nehru's portraits", he said, but younger generations are more irreverent.

"It's fascinating to see that he had things like a tennis racket, tea kettle, a shaver and even went to London, which most people still can't afford," said engineering student Amar Yadav, 18.

- 'Imaginary barbaric past' -

Often accused of anti-Muslim rhetoric, BJP leaders have described the Mughals as Islamic invaders, increasing the anxieties of the country's 210-million-odd Muslims.

But they say the authors who dominated historiography after independence from Britain in 1947 glorified conquerors over local kings and achievements.

And they say they over-emphasised Congress's role in the independence struggle, denying the more revolutionary or nationalist figures the BJP reveres their due.

Modi often criticises Nehru -- blaming him for the festering dispute over Kashmir, or losing a 1962 war to China -- to target Congress, still the main opposition party and controlled by the Nehru-Gandhi family.

The BJP's efforts to rewrite the past "aren't just about history but securing its own place in the present for the next few decades", S. Irfan Habib, a New Delhi-based historian told AFP.

"It's dangerous as these books mould young minds who'll grow with a very different understanding of India," Habib said.

"The government in power has full majority and there's nothing much one can do," he added.

Contemporary history is also being reworked, say Indian media: a top official body slashed school textbook content this year.

Among the deletions were the Gujarat riots that killed at least 1,000 people, mostly Muslims, in 2002 -- when Modi was the state's premier.

It was one of India's worst outbreaks of religious violence in recent times, and one removed passage reportedly warned that such events "alert us to the dangers involved in using religious sentiments for political purposes".

- 'Insult to India' -

The states of Haryana and Gujarat have announced the addition of a Hindu holy book to the school curriculum, despite the education system being secular.

A Karnataka textbook incorporated a speech by the founder of the right-wing Rashtriya Swayamsewak Sangh, the BJP's ideological fountainhead.

Rahul Gandhi, Nehru's great-grandson and a Congress party leader, slammed it as an "attempt to teach children saffronised lessons... an insult to India, which is the cradle of diversity".

Saffron, the sacred colour of Hindu monks' robes, is a part of the BJP flag.

Another book in the same state claimed that Vinayak Damodar Savarkar, a right-wing revolutionary jailed by the British, made regular excursions from his jail cell on the wings of small birds.

Savarkar's biographer Vikram Sampath condemned the "stupid insertion".

He is one of the young historians who support "decolonisation" of Indian history, but want to see quality maintained during revisions.

India was "slowly maturing as a democracy", he said, hoping for a time when "historical characters won't get caught in the slug fest of contemporary electoral politics".

- 'Greatest con job' -

For some, the history textbook changes fit into the ruling party's agenda of appealing to the country's Hindu majority.

The BJP has backed several big-ticket projects including a grand temple corridor in Varanasi, a mega statue to a Hindu warrior king who successfully challenged the Mughals, and a grand temple at the Ayodhya site where zealots destroyed a Mughal-era mosque three decades ago.

Now emboldened right-wing groups have laid fresh claims to several Muslim sites they say were built atop temples destroyed during Islamic rule, raising fears of violence.

Some of them question the contributions of non-Hindu rulers, and the merits of secularism in an overwhelmingly Hindu country of about 1.4 billion people.

"What did the Islamic invasions do for this country in 1,400 years of onslaught?" said Omendra Ratnu, who wrote the book launched by home minister Shah.

"They built three buildings -- Taj Mahal, Red Fort and the Qutub Minar -- and all three are disputed, have Hindu claims," he told AFP.

Mainstream Indian history was a "con job ... by some very crafty and wicked people", he said, adding textbook revisions were "baby steps -- but steps in the right direction".

C.Smith--ThChM