The China Mail - Hey chatbot, is this true? AI 'factchecks' sow misinformation

USD -
AED 3.672902
AFN 69.589337
ALL 86.196303
AMD 383.859677
ANG 1.789679
AOA 917.499003
ARS 1184.254303
AUD 1.546934
AWG 1.80125
AZN 1.694587
BAM 1.716751
BBD 2.020004
BDT 122.248895
BGN 1.719075
BHD 0.376942
BIF 2978.161263
BMD 1
BND 1.289088
BOB 6.91329
BRL 5.634397
BSD 1.000478
BTN 85.714411
BWP 13.42977
BYN 3.274157
BYR 19600
BZD 2.009647
CAD 1.372465
CDF 2865.000411
CHF 0.823703
CLF 0.024493
CLP 939.889814
CNY 7.204302
CNH 7.190605
COP 4126.73
CRC 509.280187
CUC 1
CUP 26.5
CVE 96.783962
CZK 21.88202
DJF 177.719882
DKK 6.557399
DOP 59.074211
DZD 131.742973
EGP 49.6724
ERN 15
ETB 136.603394
EUR 0.87913
FJD 2.253301
FKP 0.738134
GBP 0.73949
GEL 2.740121
GGP 0.738134
GHS 10.234759
GIP 0.738134
GMD 71.999878
GNF 8671.189952
GTQ 7.683564
GYD 209.312226
HKD 7.84522
HNL 26.067264
HRK 6.6213
HTG 130.971556
HUF 354.816026
IDR 16338.7
ILS 3.52005
IMP 0.738134
INR 85.710498
IQD 1310.60483
IRR 42125.000185
ISK 127.120222
JEP 0.738134
JMD 159.588148
JOD 0.708976
JPY 143.876503
KES 129.249843
KGS 87.450242
KHR 4012.253568
KMF 434.492751
KPW 899.938458
KRW 1377.349776
KWD 0.30675
KYD 0.833699
KZT 512.413814
LAK 21608.858421
LBP 89641.915111
LKR 299.478195
LRD 199.594474
LSL 17.918047
LTL 2.95274
LVL 0.60489
LYD 5.44659
MAD 9.199853
MDL 17.207661
MGA 4546.831043
MKD 54.05916
MMK 2099.400036
MNT 3577.427298
MOP 8.084845
MRU 39.548122
MUR 45.430453
MVR 15.46004
MWK 1734.817929
MXN 19.261498
MYR 4.245012
MZN 63.910064
NAD 17.919148
NGN 1582.710265
NIO 36.813209
NOK 10.146435
NPR 137.144011
NZD 1.666486
OMR 0.384499
PAB 1.000478
PEN 3.622248
PGK 4.110455
PHP 55.705988
PKR 283.16743
PLN 3.76045
PYG 7993.890691
QAR 3.647886
RON 4.445597
RSD 103.032985
RUB 78.977411
RWF 1415.568
SAR 3.750807
SBD 8.350767
SCR 14.728869
SDG 600.499678
SEK 9.62136
SGD 1.289195
SHP 0.785843
SLE 22.719686
SLL 20969.500214
SOS 571.77717
SRD 37.147504
STD 20697.981008
SVC 8.753697
SYP 13001.814997
SZL 17.910828
THB 32.6365
TJS 9.904631
TMT 3.505
TND 2.978113
TOP 2.342097
TRY 39.131602
TTD 6.788647
TWD 29.999587
TZS 2689.999828
UAH 41.553336
UGX 3643.641183
UYU 41.710188
UZS 12840.453265
VES 94.846525
VND 26055
VUV 120.837102
WST 2.761673
XAF 575.774626
XAG 0.028977
XAU 0.000298
XCD 2.70255
XDR 0.712934
XOF 575.759464
XPF 104.682446
YER 243.85015
ZAR 17.875799
ZMK 9001.202368
ZMW 26.862292
ZWL 321.999592
  • RBGPF

    -1.5000

    67.5

    -2.22%

  • CMSC

    0.0470

    22.117

    +0.21%

  • RYCEF

    0.1600

    12.04

    +1.33%

  • NGG

    -0.5350

    71.395

    -0.75%

  • AZN

    0.2500

    72.18

    +0.35%

  • VOD

    -0.0750

    10.325

    -0.73%

  • GSK

    -1.1450

    40.51

    -2.83%

  • BTI

    1.0550

    46.445

    +2.27%

  • RIO

    -0.6700

    58.91

    -1.14%

  • BP

    0.0120

    29.577

    +0.04%

  • RELX

    -0.5500

    54.03

    -1.02%

  • CMSD

    0.0128

    22.0789

    +0.06%

  • BCE

    -0.3800

    21.9

    -1.74%

  • BCC

    1.9750

    87.075

    +2.27%

  • SCS

    0.3700

    10.56

    +3.5%

  • JRI

    0.0340

    12.95

    +0.26%

Hey chatbot, is this true? AI 'factchecks' sow misinformation
Hey chatbot, is this true? AI 'factchecks' sow misinformation / Photo: © AFP

Hey chatbot, is this true? AI 'factchecks' sow misinformation

As misinformation exploded during India's four-day conflict with Pakistan, social media users turned to an AI chatbot for verification -- only to encounter more falsehoods, underscoring its unreliability as a fact-checking tool.

Text size:

With tech platforms reducing human fact-checkers, users are increasingly relying on AI-powered chatbots -- including xAI's Grok, OpenAI's ChatGPT, and Google's Gemini -- in search of reliable information.

"Hey @Grok, is this true?" has become a common query on Elon Musk's platform X, where the AI assistant is built in, reflecting the growing trend of seeking instant debunks on social media.

But the responses are often themselves riddled with misinformation.

Grok -- now under renewed scrutiny for inserting "white genocide," a far-right conspiracy theory, into unrelated queries -- wrongly identified old video footage from Sudan's Khartoum airport as a missile strike on Pakistan's Nur Khan airbase during the country's recent conflict with India.

Unrelated footage of a building on fire in Nepal was misidentified as "likely" showing Pakistan's military response to Indian strikes.

"The growing reliance on Grok as a fact-checker comes as X and other major tech companies have scaled back investments in human fact-checkers," McKenzie Sadeghi, a researcher with the disinformation watchdog NewsGuard, told AFP.

"Our research has repeatedly found that AI chatbots are not reliable sources for news and information, particularly when it comes to breaking news," she warned.

- 'Fabricated' -

NewsGuard's research found that 10 leading chatbots were prone to repeating falsehoods, including Russian disinformation narratives and false or misleading claims related to the recent Australian election.

In a recent study of eight AI search tools, the Tow Center for Digital Journalism at Columbia University found that chatbots were "generally bad at declining to answer questions they couldn't answer accurately, offering incorrect or speculative answers instead."

When AFP fact-checkers in Uruguay asked Gemini about an AI-generated image of a woman, it not only confirmed its authenticity but fabricated details about her identity and where the image was likely taken.

Grok recently labeled a purported video of a giant anaconda swimming in the Amazon River as "genuine," even citing credible-sounding scientific expeditions to support its false claim.

In reality, the video was AI-generated, AFP fact-checkers in Latin America reported, noting that many users cited Grok's assessment as evidence the clip was real.

Such findings have raised concerns as surveys show that online users are increasingly shifting from traditional search engines to AI chatbots for information gathering and verification.

The shift also comes as Meta announced earlier this year it was ending its third-party fact-checking program in the United States, turning over the task of debunking falsehoods to ordinary users under a model known as "Community Notes," popularized by X.

Researchers have repeatedly questioned the effectiveness of "Community Notes" in combating falsehoods.

- 'Biased answers' -

Human fact-checking has long been a flashpoint in a hyperpolarized political climate, particularly in the United States, where conservative advocates maintain it suppresses free speech and censors right-wing content -- something professional fact-checkers vehemently reject.

AFP currently works in 26 languages with Facebook's fact-checking program, including in Asia, Latin America, and the European Union.

The quality and accuracy of AI chatbots can vary, depending on how they are trained and programmed, prompting concerns that their output may be subject to political influence or control.

Musk's xAI recently blamed an "unauthorized modification" for causing Grok to generate unsolicited posts referencing "white genocide" in South Africa.

When AI expert David Caswell asked Grok who might have modified its system prompt, the chatbot named Musk as the "most likely" culprit.

Musk, the South African-born billionaire backer of President Donald Trump, has previously peddled the unfounded claim that South Africa's leaders were "openly pushing for genocide" of white people.

"We have seen the way AI assistants can either fabricate results or give biased answers after human coders specifically change their instructions," Angie Holan, director of the International Fact-Checking Network, told AFP.

"I am especially concerned about the way Grok has mishandled requests concerning very sensitive matters after receiving instructions to provide pre-authorized answers."

burs-ac/nl

D.Pan--ThChM