The China Mail - The 'tyranny of thinness' still dominates fashion

USD -
AED 3.673042
AFN 69.824515
ALL 86.361437
AMD 382.900119
ANG 1.789679
AOA 917.503981
ARS 1134.355808
AUD 1.539409
AWG 1.80125
AZN 1.70397
BAM 1.720368
BBD 2.015745
BDT 121.599156
BGN 1.72155
BHD 0.376919
BIF 2971.19233
BMD 1
BND 1.28425
BOB 6.898887
BRL 5.646704
BSD 0.998373
BTN 85.101816
BWP 13.401064
BYN 3.267186
BYR 19600
BZD 2.005366
CAD 1.37365
CDF 2865.000362
CHF 0.821469
CLF 0.024533
CLP 941.452258
CNY 7.204304
CNH 7.172595
COP 4170.119189
CRC 507.806659
CUC 1
CUP 26.5
CVE 96.991688
CZK 21.866604
DJF 177.78071
DKK 6.565104
DOP 58.961165
DZD 132.208295
EGP 49.88433
ERN 15
ETB 135.150899
EUR 0.879504
FJD 2.251804
FKP 0.740284
GBP 0.738798
GEL 2.740391
GGP 0.740284
GHS 11.031359
GIP 0.740284
GMD 72.000355
GNF 8648.45846
GTQ 7.66328
GYD 208.866605
HKD 7.832585
HNL 25.986718
HRK 6.629704
HTG 130.632889
HUF 355.270388
IDR 16246.25
ILS 3.612975
IMP 0.740284
INR 85.14205
IQD 1307.824251
IRR 42125.000352
ISK 127.660386
JEP 0.740284
JMD 158.648898
JOD 0.70904
JPY 142.570385
KES 129.023178
KGS 87.450384
KHR 3996.129657
KMF 434.503794
KPW 899.986376
KRW 1365.730383
KWD 0.30651
KYD 0.831948
KZT 510.612658
LAK 21569.248362
LBP 89450.587149
LKR 298.887276
LRD 199.665743
LSL 17.869728
LTL 2.95274
LVL 0.60489
LYD 5.454545
MAD 9.176848
MDL 17.310991
MGA 4464.08937
MKD 54.123235
MMK 2099.305353
MNT 3578.330711
MOP 8.051722
MRU 39.703567
MUR 45.710378
MVR 15.460378
MWK 1731.09909
MXN 19.24135
MYR 4.231039
MZN 63.910377
NAD 17.869728
NGN 1589.803725
NIO 36.741874
NOK 10.106135
NPR 136.163082
NZD 1.670662
OMR 0.384879
PAB 0.998373
PEN 3.652637
PGK 4.092888
PHP 55.370375
PKR 281.388398
PLN 3.746678
PYG 7964.990984
QAR 3.638739
RON 4.446204
RSD 103.109469
RUB 79.342042
RWF 1430.091921
SAR 3.750687
SBD 8.350767
SCR 14.316752
SDG 600.503676
SEK 9.528215
SGD 1.287304
SHP 0.785843
SLE 22.720371
SLL 20969.500214
SOS 570.523816
SRD 37.177504
STD 20697.981008
SVC 8.735541
SYP 13001.953138
SZL 17.865154
THB 32.503038
TJS 10.232924
TMT 3.505
TND 2.984123
TOP 2.342104
TRY 38.99279
TTD 6.786295
TWD 29.972304
TZS 2692.96741
UAH 41.440296
UGX 3644.280248
UYU 41.474249
UZS 12882.966091
VES 94.846525
VND 25954
VUV 121.378793
WST 2.776216
XAF 576.995206
XAG 0.029862
XAU 0.000298
XCD 2.70255
XDR 0.717597
XOF 576.995206
XPF 104.903901
YER 243.850363
ZAR 17.83235
ZMK 9001.203587
ZMW 27.304394
ZWL 321.999592
  • RBGPF

    65.0500

    65.05

    +100%

  • SCS

    -0.0600

    10.09

    -0.59%

  • NGG

    1.1600

    74.79

    +1.55%

  • JRI

    0.0500

    12.69

    +0.39%

  • GSK

    -0.2600

    38.66

    -0.67%

  • CMSC

    -0.0200

    21.94

    -0.09%

  • CMSD

    0.1600

    21.89

    +0.73%

  • BCC

    -0.7700

    86.56

    -0.89%

  • RIO

    0.4600

    61.58

    +0.75%

  • RYCEF

    0.1200

    11.32

    +1.06%

  • BCE

    0.0600

    21.53

    +0.28%

  • VOD

    -0.0700

    10.47

    -0.67%

  • RELX

    0.4600

    55.44

    +0.83%

  • AZN

    0.4600

    70.41

    +0.65%

  • BTI

    0.6200

    45.22

    +1.37%

  • BP

    0.1500

    29.09

    +0.52%

The 'tyranny of thinness' still dominates fashion
The 'tyranny of thinness' still dominates fashion / Photo: © AFP/File

The 'tyranny of thinness' still dominates fashion

Despite claims that the fashion industry is embracing curvier bodies, the data suggests it could be guilty of what one expert calls "fat-washing".

Text size:

While a handful of plus-size models such as Paloma Elsesser have grabbed media attention in recent years, the figures shows they remain a vanishingly small minority.

Vogue Business looked at 9,137 outfits unveiled during 219 shows in New York, London, Milan and Paris last season and found that 0.6 percent were plus-size -- defined as US size 14 or above, which is actually the average size for a woman in the United States -- and only 3.8 percent were size 6-12.

This means 95.6 percent of outfits presented were in US size 0-4.

Paolo Volonte, who teaches sociology of fashion in Milan, says brands use a few curvy models to deflect criticism.

"It's 'fat-washing'," he told AFP, comparing it to criticisms of cynical "green-washing" by which the industry is accused of making empty climate pledges.

"They use curvy models in their shows to show inclusivity but in fact this is to preserve and maintain a system based on the tyranny of the thin ideal," Volonte said.

Ekaterina Ozhiganova, a 20-year-old model and law student, says luxury brands simply "refuse to represent normal people".

Medium-sized women "are often told either to lose weight... or to push themselves up to XL," she told AFP. "Neither is healthy."

- 'Darling, that's the job' -

Ozhiganova's advocacy group, Model Law, carried out a survey that found nine out of 10 models felt pressure to change their bodies, more than half on a regular basis.

"It's very hard for them to talk about," she said. "If you complain, everyone will just say: 'Darling, that's the job.'"

How it became "the job" is a question of history.

Volonte says the obsession with thinness dates back to the birth of industrial production techniques.

Previously, designers made clothes specific to individuals. In the mass production era, they use small templates which they scale up for larger sizes.

This only works up to a certain size, however, after which fat and muscle can change the shape of bodies in more complex ways.

"It is much more expensive to produce and sell clothing on higher sizes and requires more expertise," said Volonte.

At the same time, thinness became firmly associated with wealth -- having the time and money to work on your body -- an aspiration that has been deeply entrenched by advertising and the day-to-day practices of the fashion industry.

- 'A fantasy world' -

There have been efforts to change things since the early 2000s when fears spread that size-zero models were encouraging anorexia in young people.

Since 2017, France requires models to pass medical examinations, while the country's two biggest luxury conglomerates, LVMH and Kering, signed charters vowing to stop using size-zero models.

But with sizes varying from one brand to the next, this is hard to enforce.

Designers are as trapped in the status quo as everyone else.

Elite couturier Mohammad Ashi says discrimination based on race and gender has been fairly well tackled in fashion, but shape is tricky.

"We're not trying to avoid it, but from an industrial point of view, we can't produce a plus-size dress. We sell what we show and I know our clients personally. It's just business," he told AFP.

Couturier Julien Fournie has used pregnant models and his favourite model, Michaela Tomanova, has "six centimetres everywhere more than the others".

But he says, "fashion remains fashion... It's a fantasy world and that will never change fundamentally."

B.Chan--ThChM