The China Mail - Europe court says S.African Semenya's gender eligibility trial wasn't fair

USD -
AED 3.6725
AFN 68.500767
ALL 83.650195
AMD 383.740036
ANG 1.789623
AOA 917.000168
ARS 1255.771603
AUD 1.518535
AWG 1.8025
AZN 1.699594
BAM 1.668636
BBD 2.020399
BDT 121.679557
BGN 1.671324
BHD 0.377009
BIF 2981.413623
BMD 1
BND 1.279674
BOB 6.939711
BRL 5.532197
BSD 1.000601
BTN 85.690153
BWP 13.33339
BYN 3.274649
BYR 19600
BZD 2.009991
CAD 1.366665
CDF 2885.999797
CHF 0.797305
CLF 0.024758
CLP 950.059844
CNY 7.175299
CNH 7.180395
COP 4015.7
CRC 504.651927
CUC 1
CUP 26.5
CVE 94.750118
CZK 21.077021
DJF 177.719836
DKK 6.381645
DOP 60.201883
DZD 129.786021
EGP 49.513198
ERN 15
ETB 135.375002
EUR 0.855315
FJD 2.261989
FKP 0.736163
GBP 0.736975
GEL 2.70977
GGP 0.736163
GHS 10.398008
GIP 0.736163
GMD 71.500142
GNF 8655.999873
GTQ 7.68709
GYD 209.351631
HKD 7.84955
HNL 26.350155
HRK 6.442403
HTG 131.286287
HUF 340.946504
IDR 16215
ILS 3.30675
IMP 0.736163
INR 85.73505
IQD 1310
IRR 42112.501063
ISK 122.029986
JEP 0.736163
JMD 159.910246
JOD 0.708992
JPY 146.307011
KES 129.504736
KGS 87.449424
KHR 4021.000199
KMF 421.501385
KPW 899.989949
KRW 1371.760527
KWD 0.30571
KYD 0.833891
KZT 519.10468
LAK 21530.000051
LBP 89599.999784
LKR 300.589969
LRD 200.999896
LSL 17.729749
LTL 2.95274
LVL 0.60489
LYD 5.394991
MAD 9.002495
MDL 16.930368
MGA 4429.999979
MKD 52.594017
MMK 2099.551903
MNT 3586.805132
MOP 8.090897
MRU 39.703014
MUR 45.150598
MVR 15.400468
MWK 1736.497632
MXN 18.612131
MYR 4.256016
MZN 63.959878
NAD 17.730255
NGN 1530.519845
NIO 36.749849
NOK 10.086305
NPR 137.104074
NZD 1.657591
OMR 0.384503
PAB 1.000601
PEN 3.546002
PGK 4.12475
PHP 56.449783
PKR 284.505474
PLN 3.634204
PYG 7755.344063
QAR 3.640596
RON 4.3415
RSD 100.168026
RUB 77.80135
RWF 1434
SAR 3.750397
SBD 8.326487
SCR 14.347863
SDG 600.497378
SEK 9.51093
SGD 1.279695
SHP 0.785843
SLE 22.498647
SLL 20969.503664
SOS 571.4971
SRD 37.367976
STD 20697.981008
SVC 8.755263
SYP 13001.930426
SZL 17.729878
THB 32.609717
TJS 9.681127
TMT 3.51
TND 2.900761
TOP 2.342097
TRY 40.163795
TTD 6.794671
TWD 29.258799
TZS 2629.999596
UAH 41.880479
UGX 3585.88681
UYU 40.653701
UZS 12662.501804
VES 113.606295
VND 26125
VUV 119.443863
WST 2.750992
XAF 559.644909
XAG 0.026949
XAU 0.000301
XCD 2.70255
XDR 0.695413
XOF 558.000342
XPF 102.296461
YER 241.849645
ZAR 17.74261
ZMK 9001.196762
ZMW 23.44008
ZWL 321.999592
  • CMSC

    0.0900

    22.314

    +0.4%

  • CMSD

    0.0250

    22.285

    +0.11%

  • RBGPF

    0.0000

    69.04

    0%

  • SCS

    0.0400

    10.74

    +0.37%

  • RELX

    0.0300

    53

    +0.06%

  • RIO

    -0.1400

    59.33

    -0.24%

  • GSK

    0.1300

    41.45

    +0.31%

  • NGG

    0.2700

    71.48

    +0.38%

  • BP

    0.1750

    30.4

    +0.58%

  • BTI

    0.7150

    48.215

    +1.48%

  • BCC

    0.7900

    91.02

    +0.87%

  • JRI

    0.0200

    13.13

    +0.15%

  • VOD

    0.0100

    9.85

    +0.1%

  • BCE

    -0.0600

    22.445

    -0.27%

  • RYCEF

    0.1000

    12

    +0.83%

  • AZN

    -0.1200

    73.71

    -0.16%

Europe court says S.African Semenya's gender eligibility trial wasn't fair
Europe court says S.African Semenya's gender eligibility trial wasn't fair / Photo: © AFP/File

Europe court says S.African Semenya's gender eligibility trial wasn't fair

A top European court ruled Thursday that the Swiss judiciary did not give double Olympic champion Caster Semenya a fair trial when she contested a rule forcing her to lower her testosterone levels to be able to compete as a woman.

Text size:

However, the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) said it could not determine whether or not the South African runner had suffered discrimination.

The verdict came after a row over the gender of an Algerian boxing champion engulfed the 2024 Paris Olympics, and as the International Olympic Committee mulls reintroducing contested gender testing.

Semenya, 34, is classed as having "differences in sexual development", but has always been legally identified as female.

She has been unable to compete in her favoured 800m since 2018, after she refused to take drugs to reduce testosterone levels under rules from World Athletics, the track and field governing body.

Semenya told journalists the ECHR decision was a "positive outcome".

"We need to respect athletes, we need to put their rights first," said the athlete, who was Olympic 800m champion in 2012 and 2016 and world champion in 2009, 2011 and 2017.

It was a reminder to leaders that "priorities lie in the protection of athletes," she added.

Semenya has pursued a legal marathon to contest the World Athletics rule.

The Lausanne-based Court of Arbitration for Sport ruled against her in 2019 and the decision was validated by the Swiss Federal Court in Lausanne in 2020.

It judged that a testosterone level comparable to that of men gave female athletes "an insurmountable advantage".

The ECHR said the Swiss court did not give the case a "rigorous judicial review that was commensurate with the seriousness of the personal rights at issue", and had therefore breached Semenya's right to a fair trial under the European Convention on Human Rights.

It ordered Switzerland to pay her 80,000 euros ($93,000) for expenses.

South Africa's sport minister Gayton McKenzie said "Semenya has become the face of defiance against injustice in global sport, and this victory in court is a victory for every African child."

He vowed to continue supporting Semenya in the "fight for your bodily rights".

- 'Not far enough' -

An ECHR lower chamber in 2023 ruled that Semenya was the victim of discrimination by the Court of Arbitration for Sport -- though it did not tackle the World Athletics rule, nor allow Semenya to return to competition without taking medication.

Swiss authorities, supported by World Athletics, appealed to the European court's 17-member Grand Chamber, leading to Thursday's final ruling.

The Grand Chamber, however, said it could not rule on any discrimination as the alleged offence did not fall under Switzerland's jurisdiction.

Seema Patel, a sports law expert, said "the Grand Chamber didn't go far enough to recognise all violations in this case".

"But there is at least an alert to sport that convention rights must be respected," she said.

Antoine Duval, another legal scholar, said the ECHR had implied the World Athletics rule was disproportionate.

Its judgement "encourages intersex athletes affected by these rules to go before the Court of Arbitration for Sport and relaunch the debate," he said.

There are many types of "differences in sexual development", a group of rare conditions involving genes, hormones and reproductive organs.

Formerly known as intersexuality, they occur in approximately one in 1,000 to 4,500 births.

Semenya was born with the "46 XY" chromosome, rather than the XX chromosome most women have.

Before the 2009 world championships, where Semenya won the 800m aged 18, she was forced to undergo gender testing. She was then put on medication to reduce testosterone levels.

Semenya said she felt like a "human guinea pig" and vowed to reject future treatment.

Testosterone is produced by men and women but men produce 20 times more of the sex hormone.

But how much the hormone boosts performance remains a matter of debate.

- 'Degrading' -

The International Olympic Committee is weighing reintroducing gender testing.

World Athletics and World Boxing have already adopted chromosomal testing -- generally a cheek swab to check for the Y chromosome. World Aquatics in 2023 adopted a policy that foresees such testing.

Supporters say screening simplifies access to women's competition, and UN rapporteur Reem Alsalem has said such tests are "reliable and non-invasive".

But Madeleine Pape, a sociologist of gender in sport, says there is a lack of research proving DSD athletes gain a "disproportionate advantage" over XX competitors.

Human Rights Watch has called the World Athletics rule "degrading and invasive".

The gender debate reignited in June around Paris Olympic boxing champion Imane Khelif.

US President Donald Trump and Harry Potter author J.K. Rowling were among figures who stoked a row over the Algerian's gender.

burs-pau-ah/tw

U.Chen--ThChM