The China Mail - How is Trump's 'freedom' war seen by those it aimed to help?

USD -
AED 3.673023
AFN 63.506681
ALL 82.550228
AMD 377.409941
ANG 1.789731
AOA 917.000237
ARS 1399.475019
AUD 1.397998
AWG 1.8
AZN 1.680379
BAM 1.681779
BBD 2.015728
BDT 122.589549
BGN 1.647646
BHD 0.37749
BIF 2812.5
BMD 1
BND 1.272761
BOB 6.915529
BRL 5.146501
BSD 1.000856
BTN 91.891288
BWP 13.37438
BYN 2.939449
BYR 19600
BZD 2.012847
CAD 1.357125
CDF 2174.999893
CHF 0.777135
CLF 0.022474
CLP 887.409903
CNY 6.877028
CNH 6.868375
COP 3705.8
CRC 472.609542
CUC 1
CUP 26.5
CVE 95.15035
CZK 20.950496
DJF 177.719936
DKK 6.419245
DOP 60.650138
DZD 131.365856
EGP 51.99835
ERN 15
ETB 156.54991
EUR 0.859098
FJD 2.194499
FKP 0.746518
GBP 0.743155
GEL 2.719764
GGP 0.746518
GHS 10.849995
GIP 0.746518
GMD 72.999483
GNF 8777.499786
GTQ 7.673886
GYD 209.392118
HKD 7.82475
HNL 26.570249
HRK 6.472198
HTG 131.232264
HUF 328.85097
IDR 16820.75
ILS 3.07759
IMP 0.746518
INR 91.80005
IQD 1310
IRR 1321700.000156
ISK 125.129756
JEP 0.746518
JMD 157.033712
JOD 0.708996
JPY 157.689503
KES 129.250366
KGS 87.449702
KHR 4015.000137
KMF 423.000256
KPW 900.029469
KRW 1466.20975
KWD 0.30696
KYD 0.834039
KZT 487.690575
LAK 21425.000405
LBP 89549.999941
LKR 311.094869
LRD 183.249731
LSL 16.370386
LTL 2.95274
LVL 0.60489
LYD 6.363495
MAD 9.334984
MDL 17.224255
MGA 4169.999641
MKD 52.874944
MMK 2099.938629
MNT 3586.279594
MOP 8.064508
MRU 40.12947
MUR 45.950252
MVR 15.459709
MWK 1736.503157
MXN 17.523785
MYR 3.924031
MZN 63.903281
NAD 16.36974
NGN 1395.020042
NIO 36.720257
NOK 9.616445
NPR 147.016867
NZD 1.67956
OMR 0.384504
PAB 1.000877
PEN 3.433502
PGK 4.3045
PHP 58.898499
PKR 279.401107
PLN 3.65265
PYG 6516.019192
QAR 3.640993
RON 4.372602
RSD 100.872978
RUB 79.039112
RWF 1458.5
SAR 3.753009
SBD 8.05166
SCR 13.862781
SDG 600.999956
SEK 9.14273
SGD 1.270985
SHP 0.750259
SLE 24.602246
SLL 20969.49935
SOS 571.499262
SRD 37.538952
STD 20697.981008
STN 21.067929
SVC 8.757153
SYP 110.55686
SZL 16.369696
THB 31.453975
TJS 9.577821
TMT 3.51
TND 2.9015
TOP 2.40776
TRY 44.033595
TTD 6.79084
TWD 31.742
TZS 2596.000158
UAH 43.912634
UGX 3707.955508
UYU 40.363738
UZS 12170.00029
VES 435.696595
VND 26235
VUV 119.79372
WST 2.734505
XAF 564.067572
XAG 0.011246
XAU 0.000191
XCD 2.70255
XCG 1.803673
XDR 0.702035
XOF 562.999973
XPF 102.849915
YER 238.602922
ZAR 16.203435
ZMK 9001.199023
ZMW 19.416282
ZWL 321.999592
  • RBGPF

    0.1000

    82.5

    +0.12%

  • RYCEF

    0.8000

    17.5

    +4.57%

  • CMSC

    0.1000

    23.32

    +0.43%

  • RIO

    1.4100

    91.76

    +1.54%

  • GSK

    -0.1400

    55.37

    -0.25%

  • VOD

    -0.0070

    14.473

    -0.05%

  • NGG

    -0.3300

    90.08

    -0.37%

  • BP

    -0.7150

    39.935

    -1.79%

  • AZN

    1.0900

    196.04

    +0.56%

  • CMSD

    0.0400

    23.2

    +0.17%

  • RELX

    -0.5200

    35.16

    -1.48%

  • BCC

    -1.5270

    72.963

    -2.09%

  • JRI

    0.1400

    12.72

    +1.1%

  • BCE

    0.4400

    26.32

    +1.67%

  • BTI

    1.3150

    59.645

    +2.2%

How is Trump's 'freedom' war seen by those it aimed to help?
How is Trump's 'freedom' war seen by those it aimed to help? / Photo: © AFP

How is Trump's 'freedom' war seen by those it aimed to help?

Shirin, a Tehran resident, was one of many who celebrated the death of Iranian supreme leader Ali Khamenei. She drank wine and danced with friends. But as the war drags on, she's begun to question its logic.

Text size:

A woman in her thirties, whose identity AFP is protecting for her safety, Shirin agreed to share her feelings about the 11-day conflict as part of an attempt to gauge the feelings of critics of the Islamic republic.

Before the war, huge crowds of protesters took to the streets in January for some of the biggest anti-government demonstrations in recent history. Thousands were killed in the subsequent crackdown by the country's Islamic authorities, rights groups say.

US President Donald Trump and Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu have advanced various justifications for their war on Iran, which they launched on February 28.

One of them was that it would help Iranians realise their dream of a different nation, with Trump telling them the "hour of your freedom is at hand".

"At the beginning I was in favour of the war," Shirin explained. "After the death of Khamenei (on February 28), I celebrated that with my friends."

But when air strikes struck fuel storage facilities in Tehran on Sunday, causing thick, oil-filled smoke that blotted out the sun, Shirin felt her sympathies shift.

"This isn't what we wanted. We didn't want them to bomb our national assets to make us even poorer than we already are," she explained.

Others fret about the country descending into civil war, which could spur support for the status quo.

"A lot of people are worried about the post-Islamic period. Like my father, he thinks it might get worse after they are gone," a shopkeeper in the southern city of Shiraz told AFP, referring to the current clerical leadership.

"You get happy at their destruction. But the fact that it is so costly, that so many innocent people are dying, it makes me feel horrible," a young pro-opposition woman in her twenties in Tehran told AFP.

- Still 'hopeful' -

In his message to an AFP journalist in recent days, the shopkeeper in Shiraz said he remained optimistic, convinced that the short-term pain and cost of the war would be worth it.

"The majority of people I know are hopeful things are going to get better and we will have freedom finally," he explained.

Others have said they have not fled so they can celebrate the end of the Islamic republic, if it comes.

Thousands of US and Israeli air strikes have pummelled military targets, but also domestic security infrastructure such as police and paramilitary buildings.

"They don't hit normal buildings. They hit police stations, mosques, military locations and the airport. But the noise of the bombing scares us a lot. A lot," another woman in Tehran told AFP.

"If a police station is hit at the end of your street, all your windows shatter. That's what many have experienced," she added.

Iran's health ministry said on Monday that more than 1,200 civilians had been killed -- figures that align with estimates from an overseas human rights group -- and more than 10,000 have been injured.

AFP has not been able to access the sites of the many airstrikes in order to verify incidents as described by Iran's authorities nor obtain independent confirmation of the tolls.

- 'Depth of hatred' -

While sustaining huge material damage, the Islamic republic system has sought to project an image of solidity and continuity.

Officials named Khamenei's 56-year-old son, Mojtaba Khamenei, as their new supreme leader on Sunday. He is a hardliner believed to have been involved in suppressing waves of protests going back to the 2009 pro-democracy Green movement.

Tens of thousands of people turned out for a pro-government rally for him in Tehran on his first day in power on Monday, while other similar demonstrations around the country have been reported by state media.

Ali Ansari, a professor of Iranian history at the University of St Andrews in Scotland, told AFP it was extremely difficult to assess the consequences of the war on Iranian public opinion.

He said he was sceptical about any idea of a "bounce" for the government or a nationalist "rally round the flag" outpouring.

After a 12-day war with Israel in June last year, thousands of Iranian protesters demanding the end of the Islamic republic were back on the streets by the end of the year.

"I don't think that bombing a fuel depot was a good idea, but I would be surprised if the depth of the hatred for the regime is dissipated for very long," Ansari explained.

"Once the bombing stops, that's when we've got to keep an eye out and see what happens," he continued.

"I think if the regime survives, it will be so badly crippled it won't be able to do much."

burs-adp/sw/rmb

T.Luo--ThChM