The China Mail - Looming far-right win in Germany sparks security worries

USD -
AED 3.672987
AFN 64.505413
ALL 79.681969
AMD 363.314944
ANG 1.790365
AOA 917.999867
ARS 1514.224301
AUD 1.403706
AWG 1.8025
AZN 1.69611
BAM 1.703184
BBD 2.013646
BDT 122.674864
BGN 1.683441
BHD 0.37701
BIF 2995
BMD 1
BND 1.27508
BOB 9.817864
BRL 5.108797
BSD 0.999813
BTN 95.741151
BWP 13.568577
BYN 3.014404
BYR 19600
BZD 2.010772
CAD 1.40301
CDF 2309.999892
CHF 0.821399
CLF 0.024005
CLP 947.870031
CNY 6.695398
CNH 6.69284
COP 3203.86
CRC 447.264035
CUC 1
CUP 26.5
CVE 96.354668
CZK 21.210995
DJF 177.720035
DKK 6.519602
DOP 55.480032
DZD 133.826665
EGP 51.919974
ERN 15
ETB 163.266874
EUR 0.872098
FJD 2.237703
FKP 0.746662
GBP 0.747915
GEL 2.598711
GGP 0.746662
GHS 11.514967
GIP 0.746662
GMD 73.499164
GNF 8755.000583
GTQ 7.630277
GYD 209.132512
HKD 7.84585
HNL 26.838338
HRK 6.570701
HTG 130.669151
HUF 315.286007
IDR 17876
ILS 3.01405
IMP 0.746662
INR 95.79565
IQD 1309.739445
IRR 1374849.99978
ISK 120.510281
JEP 0.746662
JMD 157.569319
JOD 0.708978
JPY 157.482503
KES 129.500773
KGS 87.449497
KHR 4051.153211
KMF 430.000028
KPW 900.000318
KRW 1374.409894
KWD 0.30843
KYD 0.833134
KZT 448.570296
LAK 22396.2937
LBP 89529.353879
LKR 330.474084
LRD 172.957769
LSL 16.267765
LTL 2.95274
LVL 0.60489
LYD 6.368434
MAD 9.527745
MDL 17.560513
MGA 4363.785198
MKD 53.573917
MMK 2099.622693
MNT 3595.947098
MOP 8.079142
MRU 40.181308
MUR 47.660011
MVR 15.450175
MWK 1733.583555
MXN 17.224102
MYR 4.078017
MZN 63.910189
NAD 16.267765
NGN 1329.22987
NIO 36.79288
NOK 9.442503
NPR 153.18619
NZD 1.74909
OMR 0.384502
PAB 0.999726
PEN 3.37493
PGK 4.452592
PHP 62.748954
PKR 277.059879
PLN 3.789701
PYG 5950.431935
QAR 3.654295
RON 4.591022
RSD 102.300338
RUB 83.749319
RWF 1470.6766
SAR 3.755068
SBD 8.000512
SCR 13.878121
SDG 601.501353
SEK 9.838485
SGD 1.27635
SHP 0.747524
SLE 24.649683
SLL 20969.491881
SOS 571.358904
SRD 37.710504
STD 20697.981008
STN 21.335609
SVC 8.747562
SYP 13002.000254
SZL 16.265572
THB 33.250311
TJS 9.222905
TMT 3.51
TND 2.943779
TOP 2.40776
TRY 48.801798
TTD 6.793432
TWD 31.733299
TZS 2640.002957
UAH 44.758256
UGX 3929.235445
UYU 40.171729
UZS 11826.842692
VES 847.485098
VND 26022.5
VUV 117.918556
WST 2.750287
XAF 572.058947
XAG 0.015151
XAU 0.00023
XCD 2.70255
XCG 1.801858
XDR 0.707052
XOF 572.058947
XPF 103.856068
YER 236.550209
ZAR 16.251198
ZMK 9001.198309
ZMW 19.520776
ZWL 321.999592
SSP 5712.013969
MXV 1.952361
  • RBGPF

    -1.6900

    68.3

    -2.47%

  • CMSC

    0.0400

    20.75

    +0.19%

  • RYCEF

    -0.0100

    19.99

    -0.05%

  • VOD

    0.0850

    17.035

    +0.5%

  • RIO

    -0.3000

    97.07

    -0.31%

  • RELX

    0.0150

    33.425

    +0.04%

  • GSK

    0.9350

    51.155

    +1.83%

  • NGG

    -0.1600

    76.64

    -0.21%

  • AZN

    2.4000

    168.48

    +1.42%

  • BCC

    0.5900

    76.28

    +0.77%

  • BP

    -1.3300

    43.25

    -3.08%

  • BTI

    0.0450

    55.875

    +0.08%

  • JRI

    -0.0300

    11.52

    -0.26%

  • BCE

    -0.1150

    21.945

    -0.52%

  • CMSD

    0.1100

    20.56

    +0.54%

Looming far-right win in Germany sparks security worries
Looming far-right win in Germany sparks security worries / Photo: © AFP

Looming far-right win in Germany sparks security worries

If the AfD wins key regional elections on Sunday and becomes the first far-right party in post-war Germany to form a state government, experts fear far-reaching consequences for security and defence.

Text size:

These range from potentially undermining the work of intelligence services to giving the Russia-friendly party access to sensitive information.

What would the impact be for the security apparatus?

The Alternative for Germany has pledged to overhaul the state branch of the BfV domestic intelligence agency if it wins Sunday's vote in the ex-communist, eastern state of Saxony-Anhalt.

In 2023, the agency classified the party's local chapter as a right-wing extremist organisation, a label that was later extended to the AfD nationwide. The party is challenging this decision in court.

The AfD contends the BfV is a tool used to target opponents of the establishment parties, and has even threatened to abolish it entirely if it wins an absolute majority and takes power in the state.

While they may not be able to go that far, the AfD would have room to influence the agency's work, such as by replacing top officials.

Intelligence services could also be ordered to focus more on left-wing radicalism -- which the AfD regards as "one of the greatest threats to internal security" -- rather than on right-wing extremism.

The anti-immigration party, which has threatened a "deportation and remigration offensive" targeting irregular migrants, could also shift priorities for local police so that they carry out more checks in areas home to large foreign populations.

Could the AfD get access to classified information?

National lawmaker Konstantin von Notz, vice-chairman of the German parliament's intelligence oversight committee, expects "drastic consequences for security policy" if the AfD takes power.

"Right-wing extremists with strong ties to the dictatorial regimes of this world, Russia first and foremost, could come into positions of responsibility with access to highly sensitive security-related information and databases," the Greens party MP told AFP.

Domestic intelligence services share information via internal systems on sensitive topics ranging from suspected extremists to planned attacks and so-called "hybrid threats", including from Russia.

Wolfgang Merkel, a political analyst from the WZB Berlin Social Science Center, however judged the prospect of the AfD sharing classified information with Moscow as unlikely.

Such an act would amount to "treason," he said, and also noted that "being a friend of (Russian President Vladimir) Putin is not popular in Germany, certainly not in the west, but not in the east either."

Could there be consequences for defence more broadly?

The state is home to German military bases and training areas, and Defence Minister Boris Pistorius has expressed fears about the potential consequences should the AfD get their hands on information about the sites.

He has called for AfD ministers in a state government to be barred from accessing classified information.

"We are looking intensively at the question of whom we can grant access to classified information," he told tabloid Bild. "We are obliged to do so, because it concerns the security of our country."

The Welt newspaper has reported the government is even drawing up emergency plans for a scenario in which individual states might, for example, seek to obstruct the movement of NATO troops.

How could the federal government seek to combat the AfD's more extreme plans?

In the event that a state refuses to comply with federal law, Article 37 of the German constitution lays out actions that Berlin can take.

The federal government can, with the consent of the upper house of parliament, compel the state to "fulfil its obligations".

If a state repeatedly refuses to comply with federal law, Berlin could in theory appoint a federal commissioner to enforce compliance, taking over some state functions and effectively sidelining ministers.

However security expert Luca Manns from the University of Cologne believes it is more likely a serious dispute between Berlin and a state would end up before the Constitutional Court.

This could happen, for instance, "if there is indeed a threat of the complete abolition of the local office of the domestic intelligence agency," he said.

X.Gu--ThChM