The China Mail - Moscow split between adoration and disgust, 70 years after Stalin's death

USD -
AED 3.672499
AFN 65.451962
ALL 80.577087
AMD 365.85985
ANG 1.789783
AOA 916.999851
ARS 1491.750061
AUD 1.416912
AWG 1.80125
AZN 1.639107
BAM 1.696734
BBD 2.015728
BDT 122.843622
BGN 1.696366
BHD 0.377075
BIF 2998
BMD 1
BND 1.280933
BOB 11.734342
BRL 5.203902
BSD 1.000794
BTN 95.468406
BWP 13.472141
BYN 3.009929
BYR 19600
BZD 2.012779
CAD 1.393215
CDF 2273.000204
CHF 0.814197
CLF 0.023236
CLP 914.502952
CNY 6.743198
CNH 6.74492
COP 3125.69
CRC 449.393362
CUC 1
CUP 26.5
CVE 96.10255
CZK 21.019803
DJF 178.218681
DKK 6.485015
DOP 58.49797
DZD 133.047033
EGP 50.177903
ERN 15
ETB 161.890385
EUR 0.867499
FJD 2.21395
FKP 0.740201
GBP 0.74154
GEL 2.610077
GGP 0.740201
GHS 11.075005
GIP 0.740201
GMD 73.497294
GNF 8774.999595
GTQ 7.628599
GYD 209.38434
HKD 7.847197
HNL 26.830633
HRK 6.535099
HTG 130.904201
HUF 315.378977
IDR 17871
ILS 2.962965
IMP 0.740201
INR 95.40015
IQD 1311.025996
IRR 1374587.49797
ISK 123.350265
JEP 0.740201
JMD 158.336044
JOD 0.709024
JPY 159.504011
KES 129.479948
KGS 87.450266
KHR 4047.500366
KMF 426.999713
KPW 900.000294
KRW 1418.620268
KWD 0.30882
KYD 0.834053
KZT 465.738688
LAK 22564.999594
LBP 89549.999744
LKR 333.612392
LRD 181.649651
LSL 16.199248
LTL 2.95274
LVL 0.60489
LYD 6.360391
MAD 9.308497
MDL 17.373275
MGA 4310.91697
MKD 53.37538
MMK 2099.846019
MNT 3597.969266
MOP 8.08894
MRU 40.105013
MUR 47.149642
MVR 15.449655
MWK 1736.000176
MXN 17.032901
MYR 4.086403
MZN 63.909954
NAD 16.197786
NGN 1360.619478
NIO 36.82706
NOK 9.514701
NPR 152.752101
NZD 1.70911
OMR 0.384502
PAB 1.000794
PEN 3.377159
PGK 4.42879
PHP 61.374985
PKR 277.795321
PLN 3.73905
PYG 5973.01084
QAR 3.635016
RON 4.542798
RSD 101.753138
RUB 83.077037
RWF 1474.223003
SAR 3.743113
SBD 8.064941
SCR 13.844672
SDG 600.500062
SEK 9.565198
SGD 1.280295
SHP 0.740866
SLE 24.549988
SLL 20969.499227
SOS 571.973887
SRD 37.722502
STD 20697.981008
STN 21.254723
SVC 8.756946
SYP 13001.999906
SZL 16.149252
THB 33.18023
TJS 9.247366
TMT 3.51
TND 2.934571
TOP 2.40776
TRY 47.833302
TTD 6.786763
TWD 32.135903
TZS 2645.502997
UAH 44.737671
UGX 3715.737009
UYU 40.062929
UZS 11954.697077
VES 765.372936
VND 26075
VUV 118.594628
WST 2.730779
XAF 569.073676
XAG 0.015509
XAU 0.00023
XCD 2.70255
XCG 1.803702
XDR 0.707757
XOF 569.06874
XPF 103.462785
YER 237.150245
ZAR 16.188904
ZMK 9001.204996
ZMW 18.815201
ZWL 321.999592
  • CMSC

    0.0250

    21.475

    +0.12%

  • BCC

    -0.1200

    84.13

    -0.14%

  • RIO

    -3.0200

    98.2

    -3.08%

  • BTI

    1.5100

    57.35

    +2.63%

  • NGG

    0.5200

    81.2

    +0.64%

  • GSK

    0.1500

    50.45

    +0.3%

  • CMSD

    0.0000

    21.59

    0%

  • RBGPF

    0.0000

    72.16

    0%

  • JRI

    -0.0300

    12.68

    -0.24%

  • BCE

    0.1900

    23.32

    +0.81%

  • BP

    -0.1000

    42.83

    -0.23%

  • RYCEF

    0.1700

    20.71

    +0.82%

  • RELX

    0.1200

    34.67

    +0.35%

  • VOD

    0.1300

    16.22

    +0.8%

  • AZN

    -1.2600

    157.24

    -0.8%

Moscow split between adoration and disgust, 70 years after Stalin's death
Moscow split between adoration and disgust, 70 years after Stalin's death / Photo: © AFP

Moscow split between adoration and disgust, 70 years after Stalin's death

More than a thousand people gathered on Moscow's Red Square on Sunday for the 70th anniversary of the death of Soviet leader Joseph Stalin, whose divisive legacy looms over the Ukraine conflict.

Text size:

Kyiv says the offensive is driven by Stalin-era imperialistic tendencies, while the heightened repression of critics inside Russia is reminiscent of Soviet methods.

People waving communist flags or holding portraits of the late dictator waited in a long line to lay flowers on his grave near the Kremlin wall.

"People would be happy if we had a leader like him again," said Yuri, a Russian pensioner.

Stalin, born in Georgia in 1878, transformed the Soviet Union into a totalitarian state during his nearly three-decade rule.

He organised a personality cult around himself and presided over purges that saw millions executed or sent to the gulag system, a vast network of prison camps.

But in Russia, many praise him for singlehandedly defeating Hitler in 1945 -- a version heavily contested by historians -- and restoring Russia's grandeur.

Drawing parallels with that history is part of the messaging put forward by the Kremlin to support the current Ukraine offensive, painted as an existential battle against the West.

- 'Won't survive' -

"Without Stalin's return to Russia, we Russians and other indigenous peoples of Russia won't survive," 74-year-old former Russian colonel and military intelligence officer Vladimir Kvachkov told AFP.

Many opposition figures, including critics of the conflict, have been branded "foreign agents", which has dark Soviet-era connotations and requires individuals or groups to mark all publications with a tag.

In a few Russian cities, associations often linked to the communist party have inaugurated monuments honoring the Soviet leader.

A bust of Stalin was unveiled earlier this year in Volgograd, formerly Stalingrad, a day before celebrations marking the Soviet victory at the Battle of Stalingrad, one of the bloodiest in World War II.

But these remain isolated initiatives.

There have not been moves by the government to restore the monuments to Stalin which were dismantled after his death.

"People consider (Stalin) in different ways. Older people, for the most part, consider him warmly; it's as if they've forgotten about the repression," said former history teacher Petr Sokolov.

"Young people don't know him very well. And the middle generation is divided in half," Sokolov said.

- 'Foreign agents' -

The Kremlin has glorified the Soviet Union's geopolitical and military might, particularly in material taught in school or shown on state-run media.

At the same time, it has downplayed Stalinist repression -- without outright denying it.

Attempts to gloss over the darkest moments of the Soviet Union were never clearer than when authorities closed the Memorial rights group in late 2021.

Memorial, a pillar of Russian civil society, had for decades worked to keep alive the memory of people who died in Stalin's gulags and maintained its extensive archives in Moscow.

In private however, some people still remember.

"My great-grandmother did not escape repression in 1945. And was repressed (imprisoned) until Stalin's death," said 25-year-old biotechnologist Tatiana Kuznetsova.

"On the 70th anniversary (since his death), we are in no way celebrating, but remembering the repressions. And, of course, it is horrible to look at what is happening today."

I.Ko--ThChM